[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Date Index][Thread Index][Author Index]


I have no idea about the context in which these opinions are formed.  And
prior to reading this, I had no ideas about the person forming these
opinions.  And, based on what I read here, the writer of these opinions has
clearly also demonstrated he does not know me at all, and thus can not 
for me in any way.

As to technology and music - music is clearly influenced by technology.
Advances in technology make it possible to construct and fabricate new
instruments.  This has always been the way since man started making sounds.
Stone, wood, metal, silicone, and light.  And each new instrument is taken
up by players of that age and used to accomplish something a little new and
different from others preceding it.  The degree that a new instrument is
adopted and can give voice to a new compelling musical repertoire, is the
degree it becomes a success.

This last comment from the post (quoted in full below) I found quite

> Take what I say as not another opinion but a judgment.  I have some
> historical perspective.

The thing about perspective is it changes based on where you sit.
Perspective therefore is not fixed, it is changeable.  And if perspectives
change, then judgments that are fixed will become obsolete.

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Larry Cooperman" <coop@newmillguitar.com>
To: <Loopers-Delight@loopers-delight.com>
Sent: Monday, February 14, 2005 2:45 PM

> Hi Tony,
> I listened and I found the comp wanting nothing and found the title
> quite proper for the sonic result.  Very, very good!
> I have found that a lot of the people on this mailing list really don't
> understand music.
> They understand machines, popular "music," multimedia and other things
> wrapped up in technology but music no.
> So I would take what everyone says here with a grain or a load of salt.
> A while back I gave a series of compositions to one of these people and
> his brother for their amusement and because the primary function of the
> stuff was music, I heard nothing from them.  They don't understand
> music as an organic growing thing, they understand it as part of a
> social order that they grew up with.  This I know because I heard them.
>   As good as they are I heard nothing new what-so-ever.  So when
> confronted with something that they haven't heard before they were
> silent.
> What I mean to say is that music has a life beyond classifiers like
> popular and technology.  It is pure expression without the need for
> monikers.
> We have a lot of highly intelligent people here who are schooled and
> well read but treat their music like vestiges of their teenage years
> and nothing beyond that.  When I say they don't understand music I mean
> it.  They have no historical perspective at all and believe me that is
> need in the music arts as it is in any other.  How the hell do you know
> when you're being a "rebel" if you know nothing about what you're
> "rebelling" against.
> There are no rebels here.  I read these emails from time to time most
> of the time I just delete them because of the banal content, people
> thinking they're really. really cutting edge and they are just not.
> I may get a kick out of something here someday but I attended Y2K4, did
> a really horrible performance myself but I am sure that I made sounds
> that I hadn't heard before based on the chaos of all of the crappy gear
> that was meant to represent me.
> Is a paint brush gear?  Is a vibrating string gear?  Gear, gear so what
> if there is no electricity? Technology has made musicians out of
> lawyers and bakers?  No.  At least not in my book.
> As well, a person playing in a orchestra is not the same caliber
> creator as some of the Loopers.  I always thought that being a musician
> had something to do with creation and with some orchestra musicians,
> you take the sheet music away and they order a pizza.  There was a time
> in classical music when everyone improvised.
> Take what I say as not another opinion but a judgment.  I have some
> historical perspective.
> Larry Cooperman
> New Millennium Guitar
> http://www.newmillguitar.com